• 0 Posts
  • 8 Comments
Joined 4 days ago
cake
Cake day: March 1st, 2026

help-circle

  • Our distant ancestors had just as much capacity for learning as we do, they just used it in different ways because that was what the nature of their daily lives demanded. Where we can recognize dozens of brands by their logo alone, they recognized plants by their leaves, useful stones, and scat. Our accumulated knowledge we pass on doesn’t make any one of us any “smarter”. Some of us alive today are not rocket scientists but have the capacity to be, just as there were people thousands of years ago that had that capacity but not the thousands of years of science and engineering that was needed to build on to take that last step and achieve it.

    Solitary living is a luxury made easier by the abundance of technology we have, going it alone in a Stone Age state would be very, very difficult, then and now. Folks who understand things like tool making, agriculture, medicinal plant identification, bushcraft, animal husbandry, hunting/fishing/trap making, and clothing making would have a leg up. Those who have all that and the ability to form small cooperative groups would stand an even greater chance of success. I’d also throw out that despite the rise of digital storage, we have a lot, a lot of printed material in the world. Even if we forget how to read, there’s pictures and illustrations. Kids aren’t raised in isolation, knowledge (even diluted knowledge) gets passed on, and we wouldn’t forget where we once were, and the ruins of civilization would be all around. You’d almost need some sort of sci-fi level disease to wipe all of our minds to get us back to true Stone Age levels of living and prevent us from understanding how scavenged tools could be used. We might forget how to forge steel but we’d keep scavenging it for blades rather than revert to stone.




  • Reconstruction was not mishandled, it went down exactly how the wealthy and those in power wanted it to. It set the standard for how those with means respond to crisis, buy low, sell high, stoke animosity for “others” among your voting base as if they are the source of their woes. The Gilded Age and Yellow Journalism came on the heels of the Civil War for a reason. Accountability for war would have been long, tedious, and if done legally would have fizzled because most people have lives that need attended to. By the time Davis or Lee was tried, appealed, retried, and hung most Americans would have moved on and barely read about it in the paper, their bloodlust simmered.

    The technology may have changed but we are in the same loop. A substantial portion of the population has achieved social progress over the decades and either wants to push further, prevent regression, or see what they gained actualized. Wishing the Confederacy had been punished is an exercise in modern wishful thinking, pretending like if just one or two things were done differently we wouldn’t be where we are today. But I doubt it would look much different if we had hung leadership, or what, mass executed every soldier who wore a grey uniform?

    And now that point is moot, they’re all dead, the shoulda/coulda/woulda of revenge is meaningless. If we want to break this cycle of crisis-elite power grab-discontent-blame your neighbor who is not like you, the source is not in just holding accountable the ones who become the faces of the fight, but all the quieter ones that gamble on both sides and then cash in when one wins without the rest of us noticing they were playing us all. Current leadership is just the metastasized ugliness of a disease that never gets treated. Removing it would only mean we didn’t have to see it in all its hideousness for a while, but it’d still come back with a new face.

    Every last leader of the Confederacy could have been hung and we’d be in the same position we are today because Northern elites and power climbing Southerners would have bought up what they could and filled political offices with candidates that promise “vote for me and I’ll do X” but never deliver or “your grievances are with the other guy whose success is a loss you were entitled to”. If we don’t want to end up here again we have to use the lessons of Reconstruction (ie capitalism and it’s handful of elites don’t care about morals/social equity/justice) and get to the root of what makes any fight for progress so difficult and makes backsliding into tribalistic appeals to emotion so easy.